1. Resources
  2. Articles
  3. PROTAC - Design Strategy for Targeting
PROTAC - Design Strategy for Targeting
Introduction:

Protein degradation targeting chimera (PROTAC) is a technology that uses E3 ligase-mediated ubiquitination labeling step in the ubiquitin proteasome pathway to silent target protein to E3 ligase by PROTAC small molecules and increase the chance for target protein to be labeled and then degraded. Since the concept of PROTAC was introduced in 2001, over 10 such drugs have so far advanced to the stage of further clinical development, of which ARV-471 and ARV-110 in clinical phase II have been disclosed [1]. We have mentioned the basic principle of PROTAC molecule, the advantages compared with traditional small molecules and the building blocks, target protein ligands, linkers, and E3 ubiquitin ligase ligands, in our previous introduction.

In spite of that PROTAC still has problems such as solubility, membrane permeability and selectivity, but its modular design strategy is a great ' black technology ' in the field of drug development.

Targets of PROTAC

As we all know, the protein degradation pathways of eukaryotes are mainly divided into lysosome pathway, ubiquitin proteasome pathway, cytosol protease hydrolysis pathway and mitochondrial protease pathway. Among them, the proteasome pathway is mainly aimed at the degradation of cell cycle proteins, transcription factors, cell surface receptors, intracellular variant proteins and abnormal proteins, which is inferior to the lysosomal pathway in the degradation of surface membrane proteins and endocytosis proteins [2]. Therefore, in recent years, molecules similar to PROTAC but functioning through lysosomal pathway, such as: LYTAC, AUTAC, and ATTEC, reported so far [3].

Pathway Features
Lysosomal pathway Nonspecific pathway
more than 60 acid hydrolases in lysosome
Membrane proteins and endocytosis proteins
Proteins, nucleic acids, polysaccharides, lipids
Ubiquitin-proteasome pathway Cyclin, fusion-associated proteins, cell surface receptors, transcription factors, tumor suppressors, oncogene products
Intracellular denatured proteins and abnormal proteins under stress
Cytoprotease pathway Caspase hydrolysis pathway
Cell apoptosis
DNA damage repair enzyme, U1 small ribonucleoprotein component, nuclear fiber layer protein, actin and cytokeratin
Calpains calprotease hydrolysis pathway
Muscle protein
Mitochondrial protease pathway Internal mitochondria
Similar to ubiquitin
Polypeptide or free protein subunit

At present, there are clinically used PROTACs targeting ER, AR, BTK and IRAK which are all tumor-related proteins. It can be seen in the actual investigation that these proteins have specific characteristics in specific tumor cells or are carcinogenic themselves by nature, which provide targeting strategies for PROTAC molecules.

What if a non-specific protein needs to be developed into a highly targeting PROTAC? We summarized three strategies: light controlled linker, PAC molecule, specific E3 ligase.

Non - specific protein targeting strategy 1: light-controlled linker

Light-controlled linker is mainly divided into two types, one is the photosensitive group shelter, and the other is the photosensitive group isomerism.

Xue et al. shielded the bromodomain-4 (BRD4) ligand JQ1 of the original PROTAC molecule dBET1 with 4,5-dimethoxy-2-nitrobenzene (DMNB), reducing the activity by more than 100 times, and then released dBET1 under 365 nm light. After that, the target protein BRD4 was almost completely degraded at 1 μM concentration (Dmax = 93%) [4].

Figure 1: Photo-removable group shielding PROTAC
Figure 1: Photo-removable group shielding PROTAC [4].

Pfaff et al. used the characteristic that the cis-trans distance difference of azobenzene isomers was 3−4 Â, which was similar to the difference between activity and inactivity length of PROTAC linker. The linker of the original PROTAC molecule ARV-771 was modified to contain the structure of cis-azobenzene. Cis-azobenzene could be transformed into the trans-structure under the light of 415 nm, and then active chain length of ARV-771 was restored [5].

Figure 2: Photo-switchable group participating in PROTAC
Figure 2: Photo-switchable group participating in PROTAC [5].
Non - specific protein targeting strategy 2: PAC molecule

The PROTAC-Antibody Conjugate (PAC) molecule comprise an antibody conjugated via a linker (L1) to a PROTAC, wherein the PROTAC comprises a ubiquitin E3 ligase binding group (“E3LB”), a linker (“L2”) and a protein binding group (“PB”).

Maneiro et al. connected the above BRD4 degradation agent ARV-771 on trastuzumab through a linker fragment, and the whole molecule only degraded BRD4 in HER2 positive breast cancer cell lines instead of HER2 negative ones [6].

Figure 3: PAC molecule and its connector
Figure 3: PAC molecule and its connector [6].
Non - specific protein targeting strategy 3: specific E3 ligase

Traditional E3 ligase whose ligands can be used for PROTAC nowadays are CRBN, VHL and IAP, among which VHL can be used in receptor tyrosine kinase (RTK) so it may be a choice for degradation of membrane proteins [7]. In consideration of the E3 ligands, beside the influence of the ligand itself on the physical properties of PROTAC, special E3 ligands can also be used to achieve tissue targeting. For example, IAP, an inhibitor of apoptosis protein, is highly expressed in cancer cells. Based on this, the corresponding PROTAC molecules were developed, which were also named Specific and Non-genetic inhibitor of apoptosis protein [IAP]-dependent Protein Erasers (SNIPER) [8].

Ubiquitin-like PHD and ring finger domain 1 (UHRF1) are over-expressed in various cancers such as breast cancer, which is the formation of the ring finger E3 ubiquitin ligase subfamily and plays a role by forming a complex with H3K9me3. Senisterra et al. screened the small molecules from 44000 compound libraries, which destroyed the interaction between UHRF1 and H3K9me3, and finally found the NV03 with Kd value of 2.4 μM through optimization [9]. Unfortunately, no relevant PROTAC molecule has been developed for breast cancer based on this research.

Figure 4: Action mode of NV01 and the optimized structure, NOV03
Figure 4: Action mode of NV01 and the optimized structure, NV03 [9].
Conclusion

Although PROTAC molecules can modularize the construction of target protein degradation molecules, the problem of target selectivity makes it impossible for some non-special proteins. Fortunately, the existing molecules can be optimized by combining photo-controlled groups or PAC technology to improve their tissue selectivity. However, the final solution of selectivity still needs to fundamentally change the structure itself. Therefore, the research for specific tissue distribution of more than 600 known E3 ligases and their related ligands are undoubtedly another effective way out [10].

To build efficient PROTAC molecules, the right components are necessary. MCE is the world's leading supplier of scientific chemicals and bioactive compounds, who can provide PROTAC-related modular products for scientists. We have PROTAC, SNIPER, PROTAC-Linker Conjugate for PAC and their constituent modules online. We also provide integrated synthesis services for PROTAC products.

Elements of PROTAC

PROTAC

dBET6

dBET6 is a highly potent, selective and cell-permeable PROTAC connected by ligands for Cereblon and BET, with an IC50 of 14 nM, and has antitumor activity.

PROTAC K-Ras Degrader-1

PROTAC K-Ras Degrader-1 is potent K-Ras degrader based on Cereblon E3 ligand, exhibits ≥70% degradation efficacy in SW1573 cells.

SNIPER

SNIPER(BRD)-1

consists of an IAP antagonist LCL-161 derivative and a BET inhibitor, (+)-JQ-1, connected by a linker. SNIPER(BRD)-1 induces the degradation of BRD4 via the ubiquitin-proteasome pathway. SNIPER(BRD)-1 also degrades cIAP1, cIAP2 and XIAP with IC50s of 6.8 nM, 17 nM, and 49nM, respectively.

SNIPER(ABL)-020

conjugating Dasatinib (ABL inhibitor) to Bestatin (IAP ligand) with a linker, induces the reduction of BCR-ABL protein.

Protac-linker conjugate for PAC

PROTAC BRD4 Degrader-5-CO-PEG3-N3

PROTAC BRD4 Degrader-5-CO-PEG3-N3 is a PROTAC-linker Conjugate for PAC, comprises the BRD4 degrader GNE-987 and PEG-based linker.

PAC

consists the ADCs linker and PROTACs, conjugated to an antibody. PAC extracts from patent WO2017201449A1, compound LP2. PAC conjugated to an antibody is a more marked estrogen receptor-alpha (ERα) degrader compared to PROTAC (without Ab).

PROTAC BRD4 degrader for PAC-1

a PROTAC-linker Conjugate for PAC, comprises the chimeric BET degrader GNE-987 and disulfide-containing linker.

References
[1] Qi SM, Dong J, Xu ZY, Cheng XD, Zhang WD, Qin JJ. PROTAC: An Effective Targeted Protein Degradation Strategy for Cancer Therapy. Front Pharmacol. 2021 May 7; 12:692574.
[2] Wang Y, Le WD. Autophagy and Ubiquitin-Proteasome System. Adv Exp Med Biol. 2019; 1206:527-550.
[3] Ding Y, Fei Y, Lu B. Emerging New Concepts of Degrader Technologies. Trends Pharmacol Sci. 2020 Jul;41(7):464-474.
[4] Xue G, Wang K, Zhou D, Zhong H, Pan Z. Light-Induced Protein Degradation with Photocaged PROTACs. J Am Chem Soc. 2019 Nov 20;141(46):18370-18374.
[5] Pfaff P, Samarasinghe KTG, Crews CM, Carreira EM. Reversible Spatiotemporal Control of Induced Protein Degradation by Bistable PhotoPROTACs. ACS Cent Sci. 2019 Oct 23;5(10):1682-1690.
[6] Maneiro MA, Forte N, Shchepinova MM, Kounde CS, Chudasama V, Baker JR, Tate EW. Antibody-PROTAC Conjugates Enable HER2-Dependent Targeted Protein Degradation of BRD4. ACS Chem Biol. 2020 Jun 19;15(6):1306-1312.
[7] Burslem GM, Smith BE, Lai AC, Jaime-Figueroa S, McQuaid DC, Bondeson DP, Toure M, Dong H, Qian Y, Wang J, Crew AP, Hines J, Crews CM. The Advantages of Targeted Protein Degradation Over Inhibition: An RTK Case Study. Cell Chem Biol. 2018 Jan 18;25(1):67-77.e3.
[8] Ohoka N, Ujikawa O, Shimokawa K, Sameshima T, Shibata N, Hattori T, Nara H, Cho N, Naito M. Different Degradation Mechanisms of Inhibitor of Apoptosis Proteins (IAPs) by the Specific and Nongenetic IAP-Dependent Protein Eraser (SNIPER). Chem Pharm Bull (Tokyo). 2019 Mar 1;67(3):203-209.
[9] Senisterra G, Zhu HY, Luo X, Zhang H, Xun G, Lu C, Xiao W, Hajian T, Loppnau P, Chau I, Li F, Allali-Hassani A, Atadja P, Oyang C, Li E, Brown PJ, Arrowsmith CH, Zhao K, Yu Z, Vedadi M. Discovery of Small-Molecule Antagonists of the H3K9me3 Binding to UHRF1 Tandem Tudor Domain. SLAS Discov. 2018 Oct;23(9):930-940.
[10] Ishida T, Ciulli A. E3 Ligase Ligands for PROTACs: How They Were Found and How to Discover New Ones. SLAS Discov. 2021 Apr;26(4):484-502.