Evaluation of in vitro toxicity of silica nanoparticles (NPs) to lung cells: Influence of cell types and pulmonary surfactant component DPPC

Cultured human lung epithelial cells, particularly A549 cells, are commonly used as the in vitro model to evaluate the inhalational toxicity of nanoparticles (NPs). However, A549 cells are Cancer cells that might not reflect the response of normal tissues to NP exposure. In addition, the possible influence of pulmonary surfactant also should be considered. This study used silica NPs as model NPs, and evaluated the toxicity of silica NPs to both 16HBE human bronchial epithelial cells and A549 adenocarcinomic cells, with or without the presence of pulmonary surfactant component dipalmitoyl phosphatidylcholine (DPPC). We found that silica NPs induced cytotoxicity at the concentration of 128 μg/mL in 16HBE cells but not A5490 cells, and the cytotoxicity of silica NPs to 16HBE cells was inhibited by DPPC. Intracellular Reactive Oxygen Species (ROS) was only induced in 16HBE cells, accompanying with decreased thiol levels. Moreover, 16HBE cells internalized more silica NPs compared with A549 cells, and the internalization was reduced with the presence of DPPC in both types of cells. The retention of ABC transporter substrate Calcein was only significantly induced by silica NPs at high concentrations in 16HBE cells, and was partially reduced due to the presence of DPPC. In addition, ABC transporter inhibitor MK571 increased the toxicity of silica NPs to both types of cells, with 16HBE cells being more sensitive. Our data revealed that the cell types and pulmonary surfactant components could influence the toxicological consequences of silica NPs to human lung cells. Therefore, it is recommended that in vitro studies should carefully select suitable models to evaluate the inhalational toxicity of NPs.